Een onderzoek naar het percentage obducties en naar discrepanties tussen obductiebevindingen en klinische doodsoorzaak op een heelkundige afdeling met extra aandacht voor necrologiebesprekingen

To determine the rate of autopsy and the rate of disparity between autopsy results and the clinically determined cause of death in a surgical ward.

Design

Descriptive.

Method

A total of 12,000 patients were admitted to the surgical ward of the Red Cross Hospital, the Hague, the Netherlands, from January 1999 to December 2002. 305 (3) died during their stay on the ward. By using our standard mortality registration system, it was possible to classify the causes of death, evaluate shortcomings in treatment, and determine the extent of agreement between pre- and post-mortem findings.

Results

Permission for an autopsy was obtained for 136 patients (45). The autopsy rates in patients who died following abdominal aortic surgery, colonic surgery, peripheral artery bypass surgery, and hip surgery were 55, 63, 35 and 30, respectively. In 37 patients (27), the autopsy report revealed a disparity with the clinical cause of death. Patients who died after abdominal aortic surgery or colonic surgery had disparity rates of 33 and 21, respectively. Patients who died after peripheral artery bypass surgery or hip surgery had disparity rates of 13 and 7, respectively.

Conclusion

The overall rate of autopsy was lower (45) than in the period 1992-1998 (60), but remained relatively high in patient groups who were previously found to have a high rate of disparity between pre- and post-mortem findings. Post-mortem examination remains an important tool that can be used to verify diagnosis and treatment and therefore assess the quality of care.

Ned Tijdschr Geneeskd 2005;149:1579-83